Uber payroll tax ruling: what it means for proptech marketplaces that pay contractors

The High Court has found that money passing through a platform on its way to a contractor can be wages. Proptech and real estate marketplaces built on the same plumbing and philosophy need to check where they stand.

ANALYSIS by Advocate Staff, assisted by AI
For a decade, many Australian marketplaces have run on a simple assumption. If a customer pays the platform and the platform passes most of the money to an independent contractor, the platform is a payment agent, not an employer.
The High Court of Australia has knocked that assumption over.
In Uber Australia Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] HCA 40, a six-to-one majority held on 4 November that Uber owes more than $81 million in NSW payroll tax on fares it remitted to drivers between 2015 and 2020, and must pay the Chief Commissioner's costs.
The case concerned rideshare. Its logic does not. Proptech has a growing number of businesses that sit between a customer and a panel of independent professionals, such as building and pest inspectors, strata reporters, tradespeople and photographers, and many of them collect the customer's money, take a fee and pay the professional.
And there are more than likely more ideas out there looking at trying to disintermediate older business models by taking a platform-based approach.
The platform-led strategy is the structure the court has now examined. And don’t dismiss this as NSW’s problem. There is a harmonisation of payroll tax across all states and territories except Western Australia. This has a national impact.
Payroll tax is a 5.45 per cent impost and, moving forward, platforms will have to adjust their cost structures to take this into account. That doesn’t help the nation’s inflation challenge, but let’s not dwell. The scarier element is if a company is assessed and the tax bill backdated, which is the scenario Uber now faces.
What the court decided
The case turned on NSW's contractor provisions, which treat payments under certain service contracts as wages for payroll tax even when the worker is not an employee.
Uber argued that riders contract with drivers and that it merely collected fares on the drivers' behalf. The High Court majority looked past that explanation to focus on how the arrangement actually worked.
Two findings matter most for marketplaces. First, a service can be supplied to more than one party at once. Drivers carried passengers, but they also supplied a driving service to Uber, whose fee income depended on trips being completed.
Second, Uber's grip on the money was inconsistent with being a mere conduit. It recommended fares, deducted its fee, could adjust or cancel a fare and could seek reimbursement. As the majority put it, Uber structured the business so “payments from riders are funnelled through it”.
The court also noted that drivers had to meet service, safety and vehicle standards once a trip began, and that Uber could restrict access to the app for non-compliance.
Justice Steward dissented, preferring to see drivers as supplying transport to riders, with Uber collecting fares for them. The dissent shows the question was finely balanced, but the majority's view is now the law in NSW and cannot be appealed.
The ruling ends a long contest. The NSW Supreme Court found for Uber in September 2024. A five-judge Court of Appeal unanimously reversed that in August 2025, rejecting the payment-agent argument. The High Court agreed.
How the market is reading it
Uber's own reading is the broadest. A spokeswoman warned the decision could reach “mortgage brokers, service-based marketplaces, medical practices and other healthcare services”. The Business Council of Australia said some businesses could now face payroll tax on customer payments they collect and pass to independent providers, and asked states to check that their rules suit modern contractor arrangements.
Advisers had been saying much the same. KPMG has flagged tripartite arrangements, including those between mortgage aggregators and brokers. Pitcher Partners listed digital marketplaces and freelancing platforms among the higher-risk models, and cautioned that labels such as commissions or pass-through amounts do not decide the tax treatment.
Property is not starting from zero. The mortgage aggregators Loan Market and Finsure had already received payroll tax assessments, according to evidence the Finance Brokers Association of Australasia gave to a NSW parliamentary inquiry into the contractor and employment-agent provisions. That inquiry has also heard from Uber and the care sector. Hireup, a disability-support platform that employs its own workers, argued that contractor-based rivals were using payment-agent structures to avoid the tax.
The Advocate has not found any proptech company saying publicly that it is reviewing its payment model. That silence should not be read as inaction, because tax reviews are rarely announced. But it means the sector's exposure is, for now, unmeasured.
An AI scan of Proptech Australia’s Proptech Map returned a result stating that at least 15 companies in our sector might need to assess their situation.
The exemptions, and their limits
NSW's contractor provisions come with exclusions, and Revenue NSW's practice note lists seven.
A contract falls outside the rules in several instances. These include:
If it is mainly for supplying goods, with the services incidental;
If the business does not ordinarily need that kind of service and the contractor offers it to the public;
If the business needs the service for fewer than 180 days a year;
If the contractor works for the business for 90 days or fewer in a year;
If the contractor ordinarily provides the service to the public generally; and/or
If the contractor runs a business that engages two or more workers to do the job, one of whom can be the contractor.
For a panel-based marketplace, the “ordinarily serves the public” and “two or more workers” exclusions are likely to get the most attention. Each turns on evidence about individual contractors, year by year, and Revenue NSW expects businesses to keep records showing the exemption applies.
The 90-day test adds together every contract with the same individual, and any day worked counts as a full day. Advisers also note that exemptions are read narrowly. Uber's argument that driving was merely ancillary to the use of a vehicle failed.
The ruling interprets NSW law, but the contractor provisions are broadly harmonised across the states and territories except Western Australia. Each jurisdiction sets its own rates and thresholds, and advisers expect revenue offices elsewhere to step up compliance activity across the gig economy. A national marketplace should assume the High Court decision will be widely adopted in other states.
The risk does not stop at the platform
For proptech, the second-order effects may matter as much as the first. A payroll tax assessment can reach back several years, with interest and penalties on top. A platform that has never provisioned for it could face a bill large enough to strain its balance sheet.
That flows to everyone tied to it, including data partners and joint ventures that share its revenue, agencies and software firms that integrate with it, investors whose valuations assume current margins, and buyers inheriting historic liabilities.
Contracts decide who wears the cost. Indemnities, tax warranties, limitation-of-liability clauses and revenue-share definitions were mostly drafted when the payment-agent view looked safe.
Partners should check whether an assessment against the platform could be passed through to them, whether the platform's finances could support a claim against it, and whether due diligence on any deal should now include a payroll tax review.
Contractors may feel it too. Joellen Riley Munton, Emeritus Professor of law at the University of Sydney, told AAP that platforms might respond by cutting the share passed to workers.
What proptechs should do now
The advisers' guidance converges on a short list.
Map the money. Trace how customer payments are collected, held, adjusted, refunded and paid out, and who controls each step. The court looked at what the platform could do with the funds, not what its terms and conditions called it.
Read the contracts as a revenue officer would. Service standards, pricing controls and powers to suspend or remove contractors all featured in the court's reasoning. Check that the documents match what happens in practice.
Test the exemptions, contractor by contractor. Identify which exclusions might apply and start collecting the evidence now, rather than reconstructing it during an audit.
Look back, not just forward. Revenue authorities can reassess past years. Bartier Perry's expert Lisa To has said in the media that engaging early or making a voluntary disclosure can cut penalties substantially, often by up to 80 per cent.
Check every state. Thresholds, rates and administration differ, even where the rules are similar.
Review partner and investor documents. Anyone sharing revenue with, lending to or buying a marketplace should look at the indemnity, warranty and liability terms with this ruling in mind.
Take specialist advice. The provisions are technical, and the facts decide each case.
A policy question as well
The ruling has also turned a tax dispute into a policy debate.
Uber wants the states to modernise payroll tax for digital platforms. The Business Council wants clear, modern rules businesses can plan around.
NSW Finance Minister Courtney Houssos welcomed the decision as protecting a key part of the state's tax base, and the Transport Workers' Union described it as a reality check for platforms.
Any proptech marketplace, smaller than Uber and less able to absorb a backdated bill, has an interest in making its case before revenue offices make it for them.
Ref: ADV-1793829098-M21







Comments