top of page

How on earth did we get here?

Writer: Mark Hollands
Mark Hollands
Nov 10
7 min read

Updated: Nov 11

Australia had inflation beaten in mid-2025. Then governments spent, pumped up demand for homes, let the bills come due and then set out to push property prices down in the last Budget. Two wars did the rest. Was this really the market slowdown we had to have?


The Australian Bureau of Statistics counted 2,657,400 public sector employee jobs in June 2026, up 60,300 in 12 months. Image: AI-Generated
The Australian Bureau of Statistics counted 2,657,400 public sector employee jobs in June 2026, up 60,300 in 12 months. Image: AI-Generated


By Mark Hollands with AI research


In June 2025, Australia had beaten inflation. Headline inflation was 1.9 per cent, below the target band. The cash rate was cut three times that year, to 3.60 per cent. Home values were climbing again.


Today inflation is 4.3 per cent and the cash rate is 4.85 per cent, the highest since 2008, after five rises in 2026. Home values are 6.7 per cent below their March peak. Capital city values have fallen 8.1 per cent in seven months, the fastest drop in 40 years, according to property data firm Cotality.


More bad news has come from Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), which reported on 11 November that the number of new home loans fell 15.0 per cent to 111,878 in the September quarter 2026. The value of new home loans fell to $81,157 million, the largest quarterly fall since the commencement of the series in September quarter 2002.


Blaming the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) is easy, but rates are the symptom. The cause is that governments pressed the accelerator and the brake at the same time. They spent at record levels, pumped up demand for homes, let their own price relief lapse, then brought in policies designed to pull property prices down. Two wars and a barrel of oil poured petrol on the lot.

Step one, spend like the boom never ends

Public spending across all governments is a record 28 per cent of GDP, according to AMP deputy chief economist Diana Mousina, against a long-run average of about 23 per cent. Commonwealth payments alone are forecast at 26.8 per cent of GDP in 2026-27, up from 26.6 per cent, according to the Budget.


The payroll tells the story. The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) counted 2,657,400 public sector employee jobs in June 2026, up 60,300 (2.3%) in a year. Public sector wages and salaries rose $16.5 billion (6.6%) to $266.1 billion in 2025-26. That is about twice the 3.4 per cent rise in public sector pay rates, which points to more staff and more senior roles, not just pay rises.


Canberra and the states share the blame. Commonwealth wages rose fastest, up 7.2 per cent to about $43.8 billion. But the states and territories did 91.6 per cent of the new hiring, led by health, according to Government News.


Then Canberra added fuel to the housing fire. On 1 October 2025, it opened the 5% Deposit Scheme to first home buyers on any income and lifted its price caps. ABC News reported 22,921 guarantees in the next four months, 75 per cent more than the four months before. Cotality found homes under the price caps rose 6.7 per cent in six months, against 3.6 per cent for dearer homes. Government modelling had promised a rise of 0.5 per cent over six years.


Ms Mousina called it “just another demand-side policy, which increases prices over the long term”.

Step two, the bills come due

Governments also set many of the prices households pay. Canberra's Energy Bill Relief Fund, worth up to $150 a household in its final round, closed at the end of 2025, and state rebates wound back too. By June 2026, electricity was 22.4 per cent dearer than a year earlier, which the ABS said was largely because government rebates had ended. Housing, including electricity and new homes, is now the biggest contributor to inflation, up 5.2 per cent in the year to September.


Global Access Partners went further in an Open Forum analysis on 4 November 2026. It found more than half of headline inflation comes from prices the RBA cannot touch, set either on world markets or by governments, regulators, insurers, hospitals and schools. Many rise on fixed dates, from fuel excise indexation on 1 February to health insurance premiums on 1 April and electricity, council rates and water charges on 1 July. No rate rise reaches them.


The RBA does not dodge the arithmetic. Governor Michele Bullock said on 3 November 2026 that “in a mathematical sense, yes, it's true that public demand is part of the total demand”. She said the Board takes public demand as given and sets rates around it, and that it began lifting rates in February because the economy was already running beyond capacity. That was before the Middle East conflict began. When governments keep spending, households pay through their mortgages.

Then came the wars

The war between the United States and Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz, the main shipping lane for Gulf oil. Ukrainian drone strikes on Russian refineries cut the world's biggest source of exported diesel. Diesel hit $3.20 a litre in 2026 and still sits near $2.79, almost a dollar higher than a year earlier, according to The Conversation. Transport prices rose 8.7 per cent in the year to September.


Brent crude was about US$93 a barrel on 10 November 2026, down from about US$111.90 a week earlier, according to ABC News. The RBA's November forecasts still assume US$109.50 in December, The Guardian reported. Australia Institute senior economist Matt Grudnoff told SBS News that even 20 per cent rates would not open the Strait of Hormuz.


He is right, but oil is the accelerant, not the cause. Strip out the biggest swings, fuel included, and the ABS trimmed mean was still 3.6 per cent in the year to September. That is above the 2 to 3 per cent target band.

Step three, hit the brakes on property, on purpose

Having pumped up demand, governments then moved to cool it. The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) capped high debt-to-income loans from 1 February 2026, warning that prices were strengthening from already high levels.


The 12 May Budget went further. From 1 July 2027, negative gearing will apply only to new homes. The 50 per cent capital gains tax discount will give way to an inflation-based discount with a 30 per cent minimum rate. Properties held before Budget night are exempt. Treasury modelled a 2 per cent slowdown in price growth, and AMP chief economist Shane Oliver warned of a fall of up to 5 per cent.


It bit fast. Loans to investors fell 8.6 per cent in the June quarter. Treasurer Jim Chalmers has said the changes are contributing to falling prices, The Sydney Morning Herald reported on 3 September 2026. Ms Bullock said investor lending has fallen much further than in past rate cycles and put it down to the tax changes.


The damage is at the top. Upper-quartile house values were 10.7 per cent below their peak in Sydney and 10.5 per cent in Melbourne in September, according to Cotality, while cheaper homes held up. Those cheaper homes are the very ones the 5% Deposit Scheme is propping up. One policy holds the bottom of the market up while another pulls the top down.

The RBA is left holding the only lever

The RBA's strategy is simple. Slow demand until it matches what the economy can supply. Higher rates cut spending, slow house sales and with them spending on furniture, appliances and renovations. The Board split six votes to three on the November rise and does not expect inflation back to the top of the band until late 2027.


The cost is real. On The Advocate's calculation, a household with the average new owner-occupier loan of $731,000 pays about $580 a month more if all five rises are passed on. Judo Bank's Warren Hogan has suggested rates could go above 6 per cent. Independent senator David Pocock has proposed a Senate inquiry into alternatives to rate rises, a proposal only.

What it will take to ignite a property market recovery

First, stop pressing both pedals. Demand subsidies for buyers and record public payrolls fight the RBA, and every fight ends with higher rates. Governments can also time their own price rises against the inflation target rather than on autopilot.


Second, build. The National Housing Accord aims for 1.2 million homes by mid-2029. After two years, Australia had built 355,817, about 124,000 behind pace, AAP reported. Master Builders Australia expects a 262,000 shortfall. NAB chief economist Sally Auld told a Senate inquiry fixing affordability is “likely to take the better part of a generation”. That inquiry reported on 30 September 2026 without agreed recommendations, and the Coalition wants the Budget tax changes reversed, so they remain a political fight.


The Advocate's view is that 1 July 2027 is the pivot. Expect prices to keep easing into the first half of 2027 as investors wait out the new tax rules. Expect the lower end to soften once the deposit scheme rush runs out of buyers. And expect no rate cut before the second half of 2027. Ownership prosperity returns when incomes outrun prices for several years in a row, not when prices bounce.

What it means for proptech

A low-turnover market changes where proptech makes money. Cotality puts median time on market at 39 days and vendor discounting at 4.7 per cent, with sales 23 per cent lower than a year ago. Buyer enquiries at REA Group, a Proptech Australia member, fell 33 per cent in the September quarter, Business News Australia reported. REA said revenue still rose 11 per cent, helped by higher prices per listing. Tools that win listings and cut the cost of each sale will be in demand.


Policy now pushes money towards new builds, which keep negative gearing and sit outside APRA's debt-to-income cap. That favours builder and off-the-plan platforms such as Proptech Australia member Canibuild. Of the 572 companies on the Proptech Map, those that help Australia build more homes, faster, have the clearest path through.


Australia did not stumble into this. It spent, subsidised and taxed its way here, and the wars made it worse. Getting out starts with governments of all levels and all political stripe, taking their feet off the accelerator. In the end, it’s the people who pay the bill. Not politicians who chose to pump-prime their way through an economic challenge.


Ref: ADV-1794294137-M28



Comments


CS Ad 3__Wide Skyscraper.gif
PTG Ad3_Leaderboard.gif
CS Ad 2_Medium Rectangle.gif
bottom of page