High Court's Uber payroll tax ruling puts proptech marketplace models under scrutiny

Updated: Nov 6
The High Court has found Uber liable for $81 million in NSW payroll tax because rider payments flow through it. Proptech marketplaces that collect customer payments and pay contractors use a similar structure.

By Advocate Staff
Property technology platforms that collect customer payments and pass them on to independent contractors face fresh questions about payroll tax after the High Court of Australia ruled against Uber this week.
The court ruled six-to-one that Uber must pay more than $81 million in NSW payroll tax on payments to drivers for work done between 2015 and 2020. The ruling may leave Uber with a further bill for later years, pushing the total past $100 million. Because the decision came from the High Court, it cannot be appealed.
The judgment turned on how money moves through the platform. The majority found that because riders' payments are channelled through Uber, the company has real control over fares before passing them to drivers, including the ability to take its service fee or alter or cancel a fare. Uber had argued it provided only administrative payment arrangements.
That reasoning matters well beyond rideshare. Uber said the decision could affect “mortgage brokers, service-based marketplaces, medical practices and other healthcare services”. The Business Council of Australia said the ruling means some businesses could face payroll tax on customer payments they collect and pass on to independent providers.
Property already has exposure. The Finance Brokers Association of Australasia told a NSW parliamentary inquiry earlier this year that two mortgage aggregators, Loan Market and Finsure, had received payroll tax assessments.
Several proptech marketplaces use a comparable structure, possibly including those that commission property and strata reports, or maintenance jobs, through a dedicated platform.
Payment flow is only one test, however. Payroll tax law contains exemptions for some contractor arrangements, and whether any platform is exposed depends on its specific contracts and facts.
Joellen Riley Munton, Emeritus Professor of law at the University of Sydney, told AAP that any business operating on this model that assumed it was outside payroll tax will need to reconsider. For platform operators, the practical first step is a review of how customer funds are collected, held and remitted, and of contractor agreements, with specialist tax advice.
Uber has called on state governments to update payroll tax laws for digital platforms. NSW Finance Minister Courtney Houssos welcomed the ruling.
Sources: IBTimes Australia, The New Daily, Michael West Media, news24, FBAA Media, Finsure submission, NSW Parliament, University of Sydney.
Ref: ADV-1793827492-M20







Comments