top of page

NSW pauses underquoting price-guide rules hours before start

Writer: Advocate Staff
Advocate Staff
3 days ago
3 min read

Updated: 56 minutes ago


A last-minute pause on new NSW price-guide rules leaves agents, listing portals and agency software unsure what sale ads must show, as falling prices expose a flaw in the ban on advertising below a rejected offer.



NSW Premier Chris Minns has paused the next stage of the state's underquoting laws, hours before the rules were due to start today.


Mr Minns made the decision on Monday evening, potentially putting the changes on hold for up to a year, according to the ABC. The latest post on the Fair Trading page of the NSW Government website says the pause will last until at least 1 December.


The rules would have required every residential sale advertisement in NSW to carry a selling price or price range, ending “price on inquiry” listings.


They would also have barred agents from advertising a property below a written offer the seller had rejected as too low. In a separate rule, the State Government intended to raise the maximum penalty for underquoting from $22,000 to $110,000, or three times the agent's commission, whichever is greater.


The pause matters well beyond agents' offices.


The NSW Government says about 150,000 property transactions take place in NSW each year. Agencies, listing portals and agency software that carry the advertising now face uncertainty about what they must publish.


The rejected-offer problem


Underquoting means advertising a property below the price the agent expects it to sell for. That is already illegal in NSW, but the new rules aimed to close gaps that let misleading price guides stay online.


However, the sticking point is the rejected-offer rule. Under it, a seller who wanted $1.4 million and turned down a written offer of $1.35 million could not have the home advertised below $1.35 million, even if they later lowered their expectations.


Mr Minns said the problem had been unforeseen but would need to be dealt with.


In a falling market, he said, a seller might reject an offer and then be willing to accept a similar one a month later, particularly in a distressed sale. “It’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping,” he said.


The market has turned since the laws were passed. Data from Cotality shows Sydney house prices have fallen close to 9.7 per cent since the end of January, and unit prices 5.2 per cent.


What else is on hold


The requirement to advertise a selling price, or price range, and the higher underquoting penalties will also be delayed while the State Government reassesses the full set of changes, the ABC reported.


The proposed rules had sat with the Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading, Anoulack Chanthivong. They included:


  • A selling price or price range on all residential sale advertisements.

  • Online advertisements updated within one business day when a displayed price no longer complies; for example, after a low written offer is rejected or a property is passed in at auction.

  • Estimated selling prices set using the three most comparable sales with records showing how each estimate was reached.

  • The higher maximum penalty for underquoting.


Before the Minns pause, Mr Chanthivong said the reforms would “put the hammer down on underquoting and stop homebuyers being taken for a ride”.


Yesterday, he said the laws had been passed in a different economic and housing market, and that their aim was to protect buyers, not make buying harder.


The pause does not unwind the whole package.


Under the Property and Stock Agents Amendment (Underquoting and Other Agent Conduct) Act 2026, changes started on 29 June 2026 and remain in force. They include doubled penalties for dummy bidding, now up to $110,000, and stronger disciplinary powers for NSW Fair Trading.


A further requirement – for agents to give buyers a Statement of Information showing the comparable sales behind a price estimate – is scheduled for 8 February 2027. The State Government has not said whether that date changes.


The Statement of Information is modelled on rules that have applied in Victoria for about a decade.


The Real Estate Institute of NSW (REINSW) had warned before the start date that the rejected-offer rule carried a high risk for sellers. Yesterday, its chief executive, Tim McKibbin, said the rule would hide price falls from buyers, and it would disadvantage both buyers and sellers, and that agents had told the State Government it could backfire.


Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James said the Government should have written laws that could withstand a downturn, noting that property prices move in cycles.


With few sitting days left in the NSW parliamentary year, the Government is not expected to amend the Act. It is instead expected to make a regulation with the same effect as a pause.




Ref: ADV-1794819102-M34



Comments


CS Ad 3__Wide Skyscraper.gif
PTG Ad3_Leaderboard.gif
CS Ad 2_Medium Rectangle.gif
bottom of page