top of page

Overseas markets suggest prices stabilise as sellers pull back

Writer: Advocate Staff
Advocate Staff
Nov 10
4 min read

Australian vendors are holding back as prices fall, as owners in the United States and Canada did. There, thinner supply held prices up in the medium term, but New Zealand shows the effect has limits.


Bar chart of capital city auction volumes in the week to 8 November 2026 against the week prior and the same week in 2025, showing a 43.5% fall

By Advocate Staff


Vendors in Australia's capital cities are withdrawing from the auction market as home values fall, according to Cotality, the property data company.


In the week to 8 November 2026, 1,734 homes went to auction across the combined capitals, 43.5 per cent fewer than the 3,068 auctioned in the same week of 2025.


Cotality said auction activity had been more than 40 per cent below year-ago levels in three of the past four weeks. The combined capitals preliminary clearance rate rose 4.3 percentage points to 51.5 per cent. That is slightly above the spring average to date of 51.1 per cent, but below the winter average of 52.3 per cent.


The retreat follows a pattern seen in other housing markets that have faced rising interest rates and falling prices. When owners in the United States and Canada could not get the prices they wanted, many chose not to sell. Supply thinned, buyers had fewer homes to choose from, and prices held up better than weak demand alone would suggest.


Australia is now showing the same early signs. Cotality's Home Value Index fell 1.2 per cent in October, the seventh monthly fall in a row, leaving national values 6.7 per cent below their March peak. Over the same period, the flow of new listings in the capitals was running nearly 18 per cent below average. Fewer of those sellers are choosing auction: Cotality's figures show auctions' share of new listings fell from almost 45 per cent at the last peak to just over 30 per cent in June.


American sellers did much the same, on a larger scale. Realtor.com, the US property listings portal, found that homes withdrawn from sale were equal to 32 per cent of new listings in January 2026, up from 8.4 per cent in January 2022. In Miami, 45 homes were pulled for every 100 listed in October 2025. Fresh supply dried up: new listings made up 36.1 per cent of homes for sale in January, against 85.9 per cent in 2022.


The result was a market where prices stayed high despite weak sales. About 70 per cent of US homeowners have mortgage rates of 5 per cent or lower, according to KPMG, which gives them a strong reason to stay put. Academic research cited by Finder estimates this "lock-in" effect has pushed US prices 5 per cent to 6 per cent above where they would otherwise be. Susan Wachter, professor of real estate at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, told ABC News in June that the market had become a standoff between buyers and sellers.


Canada followed a similar path. Prices fell through 2025, and the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) reported its national home price index was 3.7 per cent lower in November than a year earlier.


Sellers then stepped back. New listings fell 6.2 per cent year on year in January, and in Greater Toronto they were 17.7 per cent lower in February. By June, with fewer homes coming to market, CREA's national sales-to-new listings ratio had risen above 50 per cent for the first time in 2026, and national prices held steady for the first time in more than a year.


Melbourne is where the pull-back is sharpest in Australia.


The city held 612 auctions, 55.9 per cent fewer than a year earlier. Cotality said Melbourne auction numbers have run about 55 per cent below 2025 levels "since reserve price transparency rules came into effect in mid-October". The vendors who did go to auction fared better: Melbourne's preliminary clearance rate rose almost 10 percentage points to 59.1 per cent, an eight-week high. Fewer sellers, with better odds for those who remain, is the pattern seen overseas.


Sydney held 709 auctions, 40.2 per cent fewer than a year earlier, and cleared 52.3 per cent. Canberra's auction numbers halved, to 68. Not every city fits the pattern. Adelaide held 149 auctions, more than the 130 a year earlier, and Perth was about level at 17. Brisbane held 178 auctions but cleared only 31.2 per cent.


New Zealand shows where the strategy runs out.


Owners there have also held on. Cotality NZ says the median hold period for homes resold at a profit reached a record 10.4 years in the June 2026 quarter, and in 2024 Auckland agents reported vendors withdrawing homes rather than accepting low offers. But too many other owners needed to sell. ANZ said the stock of homes for sale reached a 10-year high in late 2025, partly because emigrating New Zealanders were selling up. National values are now about 18 per cent below their peak, in what Cotality NZ calls the longest and deepest downturn in 30 to 40 years.


The overseas record suggests sellers holding back can slow a price fall, as it did in the United States and Canada, but cannot stop one when enough owners are forced to sell. Whether Australian new listings stay below average as rates rise will show which path the market takes.


Ref: ADV-1794211744-M26



Comments


CS Ad 3__Wide Skyscraper.gif
PTG Ad3_Leaderboard.gif
CS Ad 2_Medium Rectangle.gif
bottom of page